Nairobi Variant: Fund communityrewards.tez

I am proposing an alternative Nairobi protocol, identical to PtNairobiyssHuh87hEhfVBGCVrK3WnS8Z2FT4ymB5tAa4r1nQf, except for one thing:

At activation, my proposal mints 100,000 tez (one hundred thousand tez) and credits them to communityrewards.tez.

The proposal’s true name is its hash: PtNairob7pXeHYjDSDn6xXbA7M6UeNtuNXmQTay1rG1nN6Y5M17

Here is the code change and the merge request on gitlab.

Rationale

Token minting is one of the tenets of on-chain governance. The only way to mint tez outside of baking rewards is for a supermajority to vote for a proposal that includes an invoice, such as this one.

So far, the community has used this power sparingly. Two past proposals paid on-chain invoices directly to contributors:

In total, 28,700 tez have been minted this way. The bulk of the development of Tezos is paid for by the Tezos Foundation. But, the foundation war chest is not infinite. At the same time, the technological and human machinery required to build and maintain the protocol is becoming more complex and costly over time.

This proposal does not pretend to meaningfully enable protocol development. Instead, it aims at setting a milestone of inflation funding that the community can base itself upon for future protocol upgrades.

The communityrewards.tez account belongs to the Tezos Commons Foundation (TCF), a community-focused foundation for the advancement of Tezos.

Over the course of several years, this account has distributed small rewards (currently 125 tez) to community contributors who have distinguished themselves. Anyone can recommend a nomination by filling a form. This program is widely known and appreciated in the Tezos community.

Read more about the most recent round of rewards (Feb 2023).

The program curators are people working on Tezos full-time. They have improved it over time to better satisfy its objectives and the goals of the community.

Additionally, TCF manages a small grant program. This program, currently geographically limited to North America, is a lighter alternative to the Tezos Foundation grants program that allows teams to rapidly prototype ideas.

Due to this wealth of experience, TCF is uniquely positioned to be the recipients of this round of funding. I have no doubt they will utilize these funds at their discretion towards goals corresponding to their mission.

Disclaimers: I have received 545 tez from community rewards since April 2022. I am making this proposal in my name only. I did not check in with TCF before submitting this proposal.

Vote

Hash Description
PtNairobi... Nairobi proposal, as described in the blog post
PtNairob7... Nairobi Variant “Fund communityrewards.tez”, grants 100,000 tez to a TCF-managed account

To vote for the Nairobi variant:

tezos-client submit proposals for YOUR_ADDRESS PtNairob7pXeHYjDSDn6xXbA7M6UeNtuNXmQTay1rG1nN6Y5M17

If you have no opinion and want to pass, you can always vote for both Nairobi Initial and the Nairobi variant:

tezos-client submit proposals for YOUR_ADDRESS PtNairobiyssHuh87hEhfVBGCVrK3WnS8Z2FT4ymB5tAa4r1nQf
PtNairob7pXeHYjDSDn6xXbA7M6UeNtuNXmQTay1rG1nN6Y5M17

Or use browser-based voting tools tezocracy.xyz or tezgov.app .

Note that if you have already voted for one proposal, you can still vote for another one later, but it won’t cancel your first vote. It will just add to it.

Note

Any baker can submit a proposal. This guide explains how to submit a proposal to fund an account of your choice.

1 Like

TezosCRP is not a technical amendment to the protocol

TezosCRP does not have a decentralized system

TezosCommons is highly subsidized by
TezosFoundation since 2018, with no audits

This proposal perverts the aim of the Tezos on-chain mechanism and inflates xtz.

Your points are accurate, however I think this is worthwhile as a baby step towards a community DAO/treasury

Recent events I think have shown the need for such a community DAO/treasury, however I think trying to go from 0-100% would be a mistake. I think we should test the waters a bit with a small usecase and see how it goes. Tezos commons does at least send its funds out to the community based on community feedback. So its a step in the right direction

I am supportive of this idea as a way to test this process and get the ball moving. I’d like to see the 100k go more to projects than some of the stuff the smaller community rewards go to. i.e. I don’t want the 100k to fund the funniest meme. I want to see it go to new projects or expanding existing projects. e.g. i’ve seen some tweets about a new mobile game, but its Android-only, give some funds to get an iOS version as well. Or fund a new free to play game

what if instead of printing money to TF (TCF is TF too), TF gives us 100k tez which should be like 1 week of baking rewards

Better would be that TF stops baking, burns all its xtz and buys 100k xtz periodically from the market, sending them to a community DAO where everybody can vote with xtz and there is a minimu quorum to be reached per proposal.

1 Like